A place for English and Reading students to write, post, and comment on ideas, art, and literature previously discussed in class.
"The one and only substitute for experiences we have not yet had is art and literature."
~Alexander Solzhenitsyn
Monday, November 7, 2011
Most and Least Guilty
This island had 10 murderers as its visitors. Who do you think was most guilty and who was least guilty? Explain your answer.
Example: I think Dr. Armstrong was most guilty. Hello! He operated while he was under the influence! Least guilty was Blore. He tried to "stick it" to the gang that his victim was a part of, so he was trying to keep bad guys off the street. Makes sense!
I think most guilty is Mr. Lombard. He left 21 men to die! I think least guilty was Emily Brent because she didn't kill her, she just kicked her out of boarding school and Beatrice committed suicide.
I think Dr. Armstrong is most guilty that lady Louisa Mary CLees might have lived if he wasn't intoxicated! Miss Brent, I think is least guilty she didn't even kill her!
I think Anthony Marston is most guilty. He ran over two poor kids in his nice sports car. I think Miss Brent is least guilty, because Beatrice commuted suicide on her own after she was kicked out.
The person I think is most guilty is Phillip Lombard because he left 21east African tribes. I feel that he was and is very wrong he left them there to starve and not just that but he took away 21 innocent lives away
I think Emily Brent was the least guilty. All she did was tell Beatrice Taylor that she couldnt live with her. She didn't mean for the girl to commit suicide! The girl got pregnant and Emily didn't want her living in her house. She didn't actually kill her. Also, I think Vera was the most guilty. She allowed Cyril to swim out to the rock. She knew he wouldn't make it. She let him anyways, for hugo. She deliberately let cyril drown in her care, and then she pretended to try to save him, after it was too late.
I think that Vera Claythorne is the most guilty. She allowed Cyril to swim out to the rock knowing he would not make it. I think that she wanted him to die because he was annoying. She made it look like she was trying to save him, but she really just let him die.
Least guilty is Emily Brent because she only told Beatrice Taylor that she couldn't live with her cause she got pregnant and Beatrice went and killed herself
i think dr. armstrong is the most guilty. because he killed louisa mary clees while he was operating on her. he was drunk! who operates people while they are drunk? and i think thomas and ethel rojers are least guilty. because they didn't mean to let jennifer brady to get killed. they were too late to care for her. it was an accident.
i think the most guilt person out of them 10 was Dr.Armstrong. He operated Louisa Mary clees. He was operating when he was drunk. The least guilty for me would be Thomas and Ethel Rogers because they were late to take care for her. thomas went for the doctor. when the doctor came it was too late.
I think justice wargrave Commited the most cruel murder, because he senticed someone to there death. I think dr. Armstrong is guilty because he knew how to help with every death and he knew everything thing that happened and how they got killed and what they got killed by!!!!
I think the most guilty was Dr. Armstrong , I mean dang the dude attempted to do surgery on someone while he was drunk!!!! I think the least guilty would be Emily Brent. Emily Brent didn't actually kill anyone she just kicked Beatrice out of the boardinghouse and then Beatrice committed suicide , therefore Emily isn't really guilty.
I think that Mr. And Mrs. Rogers are the most guilty. The reason why is they were taking care of a old lady and I think they beat her and gave her something that poisoned her. & when the police got their they made it look like she just died.
I think that the most guilty was Emily Brent...she kicked out A PREGNANT young lady..not only did the girl suffer but the poor little Inocent baby did t>= I think that the least guilty was Vera claythorne because she said no to Cyril and I mean he was just a little boy that didn't really understand the danger and besides if it wasn't and accident she wouldn't of gone to look for her...0
I think vera claythorne was the most guilty because she let cyril swim to the rock knowing he wouldn't make it and Emily Brent was the least guilty cause If Beatrice taylor wanted to stay there she shouldn't have got pregnant
I think Dr.Armstrong was he most guilty. He operated while he was drunk! Since he was a doctor he should have known better! If he hadn't of operated drunk Loisa Mary Clees wouldn't have died! I think Anthony Marson was the least guilty. It was an accident that he ran over those two children! He didn't mean to!
I think Philip Lombard was the most guilty because he left 21 people from an East African tribe to die!!!!! The tribe was probably counting on him to do something for them such as get food. I think the least guilty would be William Blore. He sent James Landor to prison but Blore didn't know he would die there.
I think Vera or the Rogerses are the most guilty. They both manipulated those who trusted them and then fooled everybody into thinking they were trying to save the victims life.I think the least guilty is either Emily Brent or Phillip Lombard. Emily is only guilty of being a tight strung old witch. She had no idea that Beatrice would kill herself. Phillip needed the tribes food for him and his friends to survive.
I think that Emily Brent it the least guilty, I mean she didn't kill Beatrice Taylor. All emily done was kick her out because Beatrice got pregnant. It's not Mrs. Brent's fault
I think the most guilty is Phillip Lombard. Mainly because he admitted to leaving all those men to starve and didnt care that he did it, He just wanted to survive not caring what actions he had to take to do it. Even if it encluded killing 21 men. But, I think the least guilty is Miss Brent. She never laid a hand on Beatrice, she just kicked her out. Beatrice's death was all her own fault.
Well I think the person that was most guilty was Dr.armstong because it's wrong you should never operate on someone while your drunk or been drinking. Well that's just wrong I think he should have went to prison for life
The most guilty person is mr Lombard because he left 21 men in east Africa , and on top of that he took there stuff. To me u don't do stuff like that. Least guilty is mr wargrave because he was doing his job by sentencing someone to death. Besides he was later proved right to sentence him to death.
There is one store that I really don't like going , that is wal-mark .The reason is that one time I buy some headphones and the next day it stop working. I try to get my money back but they just wouldn't give it back. so I really got mad because I spend 7.00 on some headphones that don't work well and I could get them some where else , so I really don't give them no pitch forks
Example: I think Dr. Armstrong was most guilty. Hello! He operated while he was under the influence! Least guilty was Blore. He tried to "stick it" to the gang that his victim was a part of, so he was trying to keep bad guys off the street. Makes sense!
ReplyDeleteI think most guilty is Mr. Lombard. He left 21 men to die! I think least guilty was Emily Brent because she didn't kill her, she just kicked her out of boarding school and Beatrice committed suicide.
ReplyDeleteI think Dr. Armstrong is most guilty that lady Louisa Mary CLees might have lived if he wasn't intoxicated! Miss Brent, I think is least guilty she didn't even kill her!
ReplyDeleteI think Anthony Marston is most guilty. He ran over two poor kids in his nice sports car. I think Miss Brent is least guilty, because Beatrice commuted suicide on her own after she was kicked out.
ReplyDeleteThe person I think is most guilty is Phillip Lombard because he left 21east African tribes. I feel that he was and is very wrong he left them there to starve and not just that but he took away 21 innocent lives away
ReplyDeleteI think Emily Brent was the least guilty. All she did was tell Beatrice Taylor that she couldnt live with her. She didn't mean for the girl to commit suicide! The girl got pregnant and Emily didn't want her living in her house. She didn't actually kill her. Also, I think Vera was the most guilty. She allowed Cyril to swim out to the rock. She knew he wouldn't make it. She let him anyways, for hugo. She deliberately let cyril drown in her care, and then she pretended to try to save him, after it was too late.
ReplyDeleteI think that Vera Claythorne is the most guilty. She allowed Cyril to swim out to the rock knowing he would not make it. I think that she wanted him to die because he was annoying. She made it look like she was trying to save him, but she really just let him die.
ReplyDeleteLeast guilty is Emily Brent because she only told Beatrice Taylor that she couldn't live with her cause she got pregnant and Beatrice went and killed herself
ReplyDeletei think dr. armstrong is the most guilty. because he killed louisa mary clees while he was operating on her. he was drunk! who operates people while they are drunk? and i think thomas and ethel rojers are least guilty. because they didn't mean to let jennifer brady to get killed. they were too late to care for her. it was an accident.
ReplyDeletei think the most guilt person out of them 10 was Dr.Armstrong. He operated Louisa Mary clees. He was operating when he was drunk.
ReplyDeleteThe least guilty for me would be Thomas and Ethel Rogers because they were late to take care for her. thomas went for the doctor. when the doctor came it was too late.
I think justice wargrave Commited the most cruel murder, because he senticed someone to there death. I think dr. Armstrong is guilty because he knew how to help with every death and he knew everything thing that happened and how they got killed and what they got killed by!!!!
ReplyDeleteI think the most guilty was Dr. Armstrong , I mean dang the dude attempted to do surgery on someone while he was drunk!!!!
ReplyDeleteI think the least guilty would be Emily Brent. Emily Brent didn't actually kill anyone she just kicked Beatrice out of the boardinghouse and then Beatrice committed suicide , therefore Emily isn't really guilty.
I think that Mr. And Mrs. Rogers are the most guilty. The reason why is they were taking care of a old lady and I think they beat her and gave her something that poisoned her. & when the police got their they made it look like she just died.
ReplyDeleteI think that Vera is the most guilty becous she let the boy drowend just to be with Hugo
ReplyDeleteWargrave Is the least becous he was just doing his job. So yea I dont think he is guilty.
I think that Anthony is the most cruel...running over kids?! Get heart!(:
ReplyDeleteI think Phillip Lombard was the most guilty of all ten guest. Cause he left 20 men all alone and all died .
ReplyDeleteI think that the most guilty was
ReplyDeleteEmily Brent...she kicked out A PREGNANT young lady..not only did the girl suffer but the poor little Inocent baby did t>= I think that the least guilty was Vera claythorne because she said no to Cyril and I mean he was just a little boy that didn't really understand the danger and besides if it wasn't and accident she wouldn't of gone to look for her...0
I think that the most guilty would have to be Philip Lombard cause he left 21 on an island ..
ReplyDeleteI think vera claythorne was the most guilty because she let cyril swim to the rock knowing he wouldn't make it and Emily Brent was the least guilty cause If Beatrice taylor wanted to stay there she shouldn't have got pregnant
ReplyDeleteI think Dr.Armstrong was he most guilty. He operated while he was drunk! Since he was a doctor he should have known better! If he hadn't of operated drunk Loisa Mary Clees wouldn't have died! I think Anthony Marson was the least guilty. It was an accident that he ran over those two children! He didn't mean to!
ReplyDeleteI think Philip Lombard was the most guilty because he left 21 people from an East African tribe to die!!!!! The tribe was probably counting on him to do something for them such as get food. I think the least guilty would be William Blore. He sent James Landor to prison but Blore didn't know he would die there.
ReplyDeleteI think Vera or the Rogerses are the most guilty. They both manipulated those who trusted them and then fooled everybody into thinking they were trying to save the victims life.I think the least guilty is either Emily Brent or Phillip Lombard. Emily is only guilty of being a tight strung old witch. She had no idea that Beatrice would kill herself. Phillip needed the tribes food for him and his friends to survive.
ReplyDeleteI think that Emily Brent it the least guilty, I mean she didn't kill Beatrice Taylor. All emily done was kick her out because Beatrice got pregnant. It's not Mrs. Brent's fault
ReplyDeleteI think the most guilty is Phillip Lombard. Mainly because he admitted to leaving all those men to starve and didnt care that he did it, He just wanted to survive not caring what actions he had to take to do it. Even if it encluded killing 21 men. But, I think the least guilty is Miss Brent. She never laid a hand on Beatrice, she just kicked her out. Beatrice's death was all her own fault.
ReplyDeleteAfter the move the person that was pretending to be Lombard is the least guilty.
ReplyDeleteWell I think the person that was most guilty was Dr.armstong because it's wrong you should never operate on someone while your drunk or been drinking. Well that's just wrong I think he should have went to prison for life
ReplyDeleteThe most guilty person is mr Lombard because he left 21 men in east Africa , and on top of that he took there stuff. To me u don't do stuff like that. Least guilty is mr wargrave because he was doing his job by sentencing someone to death. Besides he was later proved right to sentence him to death.
ReplyDeleteThere is one store that I really don't like going , that is wal-mark .The reason is that one time I buy some headphones and the next day it stop working. I try to get my money back but they just wouldn't give it back. so I really got mad because I spend 7.00 on some headphones that don't work well and I could get them some where else , so I really don't give them no pitch forks
ReplyDelete